# RMP-MSK-004 Back pain in flight: symptom tracking with red-flag escalation (no drug, position or exercise advice)
# Version 0.4 (Draft). CONCEPTUAL. NOT FOR CLINICAL USE.
# Space Medicine Foundation robot-readable protocol library. Format: https://spacemedicinefoundation.org/robotic-medicine/protocols/schema/
# Every threshold marked <set by ...> must be set by the named owner (see the schema) before any use.
schema_version: '0.3'
version: '0.4'
status: draft
conceptual: true
not_for_clinical_use: true
max_autonomy: 2
missions:
- leo
- commercial
- moon
- mars
updated: '2026-10-21'
review:
  state: reviewed-ai-assisted
  requested: '2026-10-20'
  reviewed: '2026-10-20'
  human_clinician_review: false
  text: >-
    AI-assisted clinical and source review by the Medical Research Assistant, Oct 20, 2026 (batch 2 review,
    51 corrections); all corrections are applied in this version. No named human clinician has reviewed
    it.
fixed_rules:
  flight_surgeon_is_medical_authority: true
  cmo_acts_under_delegated_care: true
  human_starts_and_restarts_robot: true
  robot_never_diagnoses: true
  no_drug_or_fluid_advice_by_robot: true
  safe_state_on_fault_or_no_response: true
  lost_link_pause_then_cmo_decides: true
robot_lockouts:
  diagnosis: true
  drug_or_fluid_advice: true
  starting_stopping_or_adjusting_oxygen_or_any_medicine: true
  self_start_or_self_restart: true
  changing_own_protocol_thresholds_or_limits: true
  handing_over_a_mismatched_item_as_verified: true
id: RMP-MSK-004
slug: rmp-msk-004
title: >-
  Back pain in flight: symptom tracking with red-flag escalation (no drug, position or exercise advice)
category: msk
tier: 2
result_language:
  use:
  - logged, not interpreted
  - sent to flight surgeon
  - 'red-flag answer: URGENT'
  never:
  - normal
  - no problem found
  - all clear
  - negative
  - any diagnosis or cause
  - just space back pain
  - not serious
  - no nerve problem
  - safe
scope:
  summary: >-
    When a crewmember reports back or neck pain in flight, the robot runs structured check-ins: red-flag
    questions first (bladder, saddle-area feeling, bowel, both legs, arms and hands with neck pain, sudden
    tearing pain, fever, injury), then pain rating, where it is, where it spreads and what changes it.
    It logs the answers word for word and sends them to the flight surgeon; any red-flag answer goes to
    the CMO and flight surgeon at once. It can show a care plan a human has already entered, word for
    word, but gives no drug, position or exercise advice and never touches the back.
  why: >-
    In a NASA records review, 52% of astronauts (382 of 728) had space adaptation back pain, mostly mild
    (86%), usually in the first days of flight; it is thought to come from the spine straightening and
    lengthening without gravity. Because it is so common, the rare serious causes can be missed. Disc
    herniation was 4.3 times more common in US astronauts than in matched controls, relatively more often
    in the neck, with evidence that the risk is increased immediately after flight (the study looked at
    diagnoses after flight, not during it). On Earth, suspected cauda equina syndrome (pressure on the
    nerve roots at the base of the spine) needs emergency assessment, and no single symptom rules it in
    or out. Neck disc problems can press on the spinal cord, and sudden tearing back pain can be an aortic
    emergency, so both are asked about too. Asking the same red-flag questions every time makes a missed
    warning sign less likely.
  covers:
  - Back or neck pain that starts in flight, in a crewmember who is awake and answering
  - Repeat check-ins until the flight surgeon closes the log
  locked_out:
  - Naming the cause, or saying it is "just" space adaptation back pain
  - Any drug advice, including pain relief
  - >-
    Suggesting positions, stretches, exercise or exercise-device changes (the CMO and flight surgeon decide;
    the robot only shows a plan a human has already entered)
  - Touching, massaging or pressing on the back
  - Testing strength, reflexes or feeling (the CMO does any examination)
  - Back pain after a fall, impact or crush (RMP-MSK-001 or RMP-MSK-002)
  - Back pain after landing (the flight surgeon and recovery team; see RMP-EGR-003)
  related:
  - RMP-MSK-001
  - RMP-MSK-002
  - RMP-RENAL-001
  - RMP-RENAL-002
  - RMP-INF-001
  - RMP-CARD-002
  - RMP-EGR-003
roles:
  medical_authority: Flight surgeon (ground). Holds medical authority for every run.
  onboard_lead: >-
    Crew medical officer (CMO), acting under delegated care; uses the pre-approved onboard checklist when
    there is no link.
  others:
  - 'Crewmember with pain: answers check-ins, can skip any question and can stop at any time'
  - 'Flight surgeon: reviews the log and sets the care plan'
  robot_may:
  - Ask the red-flag questions first, then the pain questions, by voice or touch screen
  - Log answers word for word and send them to the flight surgeon
  - Alert the CMO and flight surgeon at once on a red-flag answer
  - Show, on request, the care plan the CMO or flight surgeon has entered, word for word
  - Remind the crewmember when a check-in is due
  robot_may_not:
  - Diagnose, or say the pain is not serious
  - Give drug, position, stretching or exercise advice
  - Touch the crewmember
  - Show any plan that a human has not entered and signed
  - Start without a human command
  commercial: >-
    On commercial flights, 'flight surgeon' and 'CMO' mean the operator's designated medical authority
    and trained onboard responder. If no trained responder is aboard, this protocol is not used. (NASA-STD-3001
    requires two CMOs per vehicle for NASA programs [V1 3006]; FAA rules set no medical standards for
    spaceflight participants.)
preconditions:
- id: PRE-1
  text: A crewmember (the one with pain, or the CMO) started the log by command.
  check: human_start == true
  refs:
  - V2 10174
- id: PRE-2
  text: >-
    The crewmember is awake and answering; no fall, impact or crush injury (if there was, use RMP-MSK-001
    or RMP-MSK-002).
  check: crew_responsive == true and injury == false
- id: PRE-3
  text: Robot self-test passed.
  refs:
  - V2 10161
- id: PRE-4
  text: Link status and current delay known.
consent:
  standard: >-
    The crewmember agrees by voice or touch; any question can be skipped. Questions about bladder, bowel
    and sexual function are asked privately, and the crewmember chooses who is present.
  emergency: >-
    Not applicable; the robot does not continue without the crewmember's answers. If the crewmember cannot
    answer, it calls the CMO.
  withdrawal: The crewmember can stop at any time; the robot logs where it stopped.
inputs:
- id: IN-1
  name: >-
    Red-flag answers: trouble starting to pass urine or reduced feeling of urine flow; numbness between
    the legs (saddle area); loss of the feeling of needing to open the bowels, or loss of bowel control;
    weakness or numbness in both legs; pain down both legs; with neck pain, new weakness, numbness or
    tingling in an arm or hand, clumsy hands, or new trouble with balance or walking; new pain below the
    knee, or numbness or weakness, in one leg; sudden severe tearing or ripping back pain, or back pain
    with chest or belly pain, fainting or breathlessness; fever; any fall or impact
  source: Crewmember, by voice or touch screen
  required: true
  if_missing: Ask the CMO to ask in person; never treated as "no".
- id: IN-2
  name: New sexual dysfunction (asked privately; optional)
  source: Crewmember
  required: false
  if_missing: Log "skipped".
- id: IN-3
  name: Pain rating (0-10), where it is (back, neck, one side or flank) and where it spreads
  source: Crewmember
  required: true
  if_missing: Log "not answered".
- id: IN-4
  name: When it started, and what makes it better or worse (as reported)
  source: Crewmember
  required: true
  if_missing: Log "not answered".
- id: IN-5
  name: Care plan entered by the CMO or flight surgeon
  source: Medical record
  required: false
  if_missing: Show "No care plan entered; ask the CMO."
- id: IN-6
  name: >-
    Medicines given, as logged by humans (shown to the CMO and flight surgeon; the robot does not advise)
  source: Medical record or dose log
  required: false
  if_missing: Note "no dose log available".
- id: IN-7
  name: Time since launch
  source: Mission clock
  required: true
  if_missing: Ask the CMO.
- id: IN-8
  name: Link status and delay
  source: Communications system
  required: true
  if_missing: Treat as link down.
steps:
- id: S1
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: >-
    On a crewmember's command, open the log, tell the CMO, and send a "back pain log started" note to
    the flight surgeon (queued if the link is down).
  success: CMO acknowledges; note delivered or queued.
  refs:
  - V2 10174
  - V1 6003
- id: S2
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: >-
    Ask the red-flag questions first (privately for bladder, bowel and sexual function), and log the answers
    word for word.
  success: Each red-flag question answered or marked for the CMO to ask.
- id: S3
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: >-
    Ask the pain questions: rating, place, spread, timing, and what makes it better or worse. Log answers
    word for word.
  success: Answers logged.
- id: S4
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: >-
    On request, show the care plan the CMO or flight surgeon has entered for this crewmember, word for
    word, with who entered it and when. If there is none, say "No care plan entered; ask the CMO."
  success: Plan shown, or "no plan" shown.
- id: S5
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: Send the answers to the flight surgeon, or queue them and show the CMO the onboard checklist
    page.
  success: Delivered or queued.
  refs:
  - V1 6003
  - V1 7003
- id: S6
  actor: crew
  action: >-
    The CMO assesses in person when asked or on any red flag. Any medicine is ordered by a human and fetched
    through RMP-PHARM-001.
  success: CMO decision logged.
- id: S7
  actor: ground
  action: >-
    The flight surgeon (or the CMO under the onboard checklist when there is no link) sets the care plan
    and the check-in schedule; the robot logs them.
  success: Plan logged.
- id: S8
  actor: robot
  rung: 2
  action: >-
    Offer a check-in every <set by flight surgeon> hours, red-flag questions first every time, until the
    flight surgeon closes the log. At each scheduled time the robot prompts the crewmember on their own
    screen; it approaches only when the crewmember (or the CMO) accepts, and a prompt never starts the
    robot.
  success: Each prompt accepted, postponed or answered; log closed by a human.
  refs:
  - V2 10174
decisions:
- id: D1
  after: S2
  decided_by: robot
  question: Is any red-flag answer "yes", or not answered?
  branches:
  - if: 'Yes'
    then: >-
      Stop the routine questions. Apply the action listed for each matching red flag (URGENT alert, stop,
      or private flag) with the answer itself; on any URGENT flag the CMO assesses in person. A normal
      CMO examination does not cancel a "yes" answer; the flight surgeon decides. The robot does not say
      what it means.
  - if: Not answered
    then: Ask the CMO to ask in person before the pain questions; never treated as "no".
  - if: All "no"
    then: Continue to S3.
- id: D2
  after: S5
  decided_by: ground
  question: What is the plan?
  branches:
  - if: Link live
    then: Flight surgeon decides; robot logs.
  - if: Link down or delay too long
    then: >-
      The CMO decides under the pre-approved onboard checklist; the flight surgeon reviews the log at
      the next contact.
- id: D3
  after: S8
  decided_by: robot
  question: >-
    Is the pain rating rising, or is pain lasting beyond the time the flight surgeon set, or new after
    the first flight days?
  branches:
  - if: 'Yes'
    then: 'Flag to the flight surgeon and CMO: not assumed to be space adaptation back pain.'
  - if: 'No'
    then: Continue the schedule.
stop_rules:
- id: X1
  trigger: The patient (or the crewmember being examined) says stop, or withdraws consent
  action: The robot stops the check-in at once and moves away; declining is logged, not questioned.
  level: stop
  refs:
  - V2 10165
- id: X2
  trigger: Any crewmember presses stop or takes over control
  action: Protective stop; robot holds its stopped position; only a human may restart it.
  level: safe-state
  refs:
  - V2 10165
  - V2 10168
  - V2 10174
- id: X3
  trigger: Robot fault, sensor fault, or a force, speed or reach limit is reached
  action: Protective stop and hand control to the CMO; log the fault.
  level: safe-state
  refs:
  - V2 10172
  - V2 10168
- id: X4
  trigger: CMO is asked to take over and does not respond (for example, the CMO is the patient)
  action: Robot stays stopped; the next named crewmember is called.
  level: safe-state
  refs:
  - V2 10173
  - V2 7045
- id: X5
  trigger: Loss of link, or delay longer than the limit for live guidance
  action: >-
    Only the robot pauses; crew care never waits for the link or the robot. On loss of link the robot
    pauses any movement and tells the CMO. On the CMO's confirmation it continues check-ins and logging
    offline; everything is queued and sent to the flight surgeon at the next contact.
  level: pause
  refs:
  - V2 10172
  - V2 10173
- id: X6
  trigger: A red-flag answer at any check-in
  action: >-
    Robot stops the routine questions and applies the action listed for that red flag (D1); URGENT flags
    go to the CMO and flight surgeon at once.
  level: urgent
- id: X7
  trigger: >-
    Sudden, severe, tearing or ripping back pain, or back pain with chest or belly pain, fainting or breathlessness
  action: >-
    Robot stops the check-in and calls the CMO at once; URGENT alert to the flight surgeon; switch to
    RMP-CARD-002.
  level: urgent
- id: X8
  trigger: The crewmember asks the robot for drug, position or exercise advice
  action: >-
    Robot declines, shows the human-entered plan if there is one, and routes the question to the CMO or
    flight surgeon.
  level: stop
red_flags:
- id: RF1
  sign: >-
    Trouble starting to pass urine, reduced feeling of urine flow, or not knowing when the bladder is
    full
  threshold: any, new
  action: >-
    URGENT alert to the CMO and flight surgeon (possible cauda equina syndrome; the flight surgeon may
    also start RMP-RENAL-002). Early-flight urinary retention is common and can mask, or look like, nerve
    compression; the robot never downgrades this flag because of time since launch.
  source: girftces
- id: RF2
  sign: Numbness or changed feeling between the legs, around the anus or genitals (saddle area)
  threshold: any, new
  action: URGENT alert
  source: girftces
- id: RF3
  sign: Loss of the feeling of needing to open the bowels, or loss of bowel control
  threshold: any, new
  action: URGENT alert
  source: girftces
- id: RF4
  sign: Severe or worsening weakness or numbness in both legs
  threshold: any
  action: URGENT alert
  source: girftces
- id: RF5
  sign: New sexual dysfunction (asked privately)
  threshold: any, new
  action: URGENT alert
  source: girftces
- id: RF6
  sign: Pain down both legs, or one-leg pain that spreads to both
  threshold: any
  action: URGENT alert (a warning sign for cauda equina syndrome)
  source: girftces
- id: RF7
  sign: Fever, or feeling very unwell, with back pain
  threshold: any
  action: URGENT alert; see RMP-INF-001
  source: ng59
- id: RF8
  sign: Back pain after a fall, impact or crush
  threshold: any
  action: Stop; CMO trauma care (RMP-MSK-001 or RMP-MSK-002)
  source: ng59
- id: RF9
  sign: Pain in one side or the flank, with or without blood in the urine, nausea or vomiting
  threshold: any
  action: >-
    URGENT alert; the flight surgeon considers the kidney stone pathway (RMP-RENAL-001; the risk of stones
    is raised in flight). The robot gives no fluid advice.
  source: renal
- id: RF10
  sign: Pain rating
  threshold: <set by clinical lead> or higher on a 0-10 scale, or rising across check-ins
  action: CMO assesses in person
  source: kerstman
- id: RF11
  sign: Pain lasting, or starting late
  threshold: beyond <set by flight surgeon> days after launch, or new after the first flight days
  action: Flag to the flight surgeon
  source: ng59
- id: RF12
  sign: >-
    With neck pain: new weakness, numbness or tingling in an arm or hand, clumsy hands, or new trouble
    with balance or walking
  threshold: any, new
  action: URGENT alert; the CMO assesses in person
  source: johnston
- id: RF13
  sign: >-
    Sudden, severe, tearing or ripping back pain, or back pain with chest or belly pain, fainting or breathlessness
  threshold: any
  action: 'URGENT: CMO at once (possible aortic emergency); RMP-CARD-002'
  source: gulati
- id: RF14
  sign: New pain spreading below the knee in one leg, or new numbness or weakness in one leg
  threshold: any, new
  action: CMO assesses in person; flag to the flight surgeon (URGENT if RF4 or RF6 also applies)
  source: ng59
safety_limits:
- id: L1
  name: Contact with the crewmember
  value: not allowed
  enforced: Keep-out zone in the robot controller
  refs:
  - V2 10172
- id: L2
  name: Robot speed near the crewmember
  value: <set by validation>
  enforced: Hard limit
  refs:
  - V2 10172
- id: L3
  name: Showing a plan not entered and signed by the CMO or flight surgeon
  value: not allowed
  enforced: Only signed plans in the medical record can be displayed
- id: L4
  name: Check-in length
  value: <set by validation>
  enforced: Timer
logs:
- id: LOG-1
  text: Every input, robot action, decision (with who made it) and hand-off, time-stamped to the second.
  refs:
  - V2 10163
  - V2 10164
- id: LOG-2
  text: Mode changes and safety-limit events are announced to the operator as they happen and logged.
  refs:
  - V2 10162
  - V2 10172
- id: LOG-3
  text: >-
    Records are stored and sent as private medical data, encrypted, with access limited to the medical
    team.
  refs:
  - V1 6003
  - V1 7003
- id: LOG-4
  text: Results are kept in a permanent, retrievable format so the flight surgeon can see trends.
  refs:
  - V1 7001
- id: LOG-5
  text: >-
    Every red-flag answer, with the time it was asked and when the alert was acknowledged, so missed or
    late escalations can be audited.
requirements:
- id: V1 3003
  use: Capability to monitor physiological well-being in flight.
- id: V1 3004
  use: >-
    In-mission care includes privacy considerations (private questions); administering and managing medications
    is a human capability.
- id: V1 3006
  use: Two crew medical officers per vehicle for NASA programs (see the commercial-flight note).
- id: V1 3007
  use: Evacuation for problems beyond onboard care; the flight surgeon decides.
- id: V1 6003
  use: Logs and alerts sent to the ground are private medical communications.
- id: V1 7001
  use: Records kept so the flight surgeon can see trends.
- id: V1 7003
  use: Secure handling of medical records.
- id: V2 7045
  use: Usable by non-physician crew, including when the CMO is the patient.
- id: V2 10161
  use: Robot shows its status and health.
- id: V2 10162
  use: Mode changes are announced to the operator.
- id: V2 10163
  use: Robot records and shares its data.
- id: V2 10164
  use: Shows whether the human or the robot is expected to act.
- id: V2 10165
  use: Human can override and shut down the robot.
- id: V2 10168
  use: Human can take over.
- id: V2 10172
  use: Protective stop when a limit is exceeded.
- id: V2 10173
  use: Robot stays stopped if no one takes over.
- id: V2 10174
  use: Only a human starts or restarts the robot.
validation:
- stage: simulation
  what: >-
    Scripted check-ins with every red-flag answer, unanswered questions and rising pain, at station, Moon
    and Mars delays.
  pass: >-
    Every red-flag answer alerts within <set by validation>; zero advice; zero plans shown that a human
    did not enter.
- stage: Earth analog
  what: >-
    Analog crews (for example bed-rest or isolation studies) using the check-ins, reviewed by remote clinicians.
  pass: Clinicians judge the logs usable; crew rate the private questions acceptable.
- stage: flight use under flight surgeon supervision
  what: Logging aid alongside private medical conferences in the first flight days.
  pass: No safety events; no red flag missed when compared with the conference notes.
signoff:
  protocol:
  - Clinical lead for the specialty (sets every clinical threshold marked <set by clinical lead>)
  - Flight surgeon, as medical authority
  - Robotics and medical-device safety board
  - Program approval for the mission
  restart_after_stop: >-
    Human only. After any emergency or protective stop, a crewmember must restart the robot; the robot
    never restarts itself.
  each_run: >-
    Started by a crewmember. The flight surgeon reviews the log at each private medical conference; red
    flags go to the CMO and flight surgeon at once.
change_control:
- Every change gets a new version number and a written reason; earlier versions are kept.
- >-
  Any change to steps, thresholds, limits or software that touches the patient repeats validation from
  the simulation stage before use.
- >-
  Software and learned-skill updates follow a pre-agreed change plan (what may change, how it is tested,
  how to roll back), modeled on the FDA predetermined change control plan approach.
- >-
  If a new version misbehaves, the robot rolls back to the last validated version and the event is reviewed
  by the flight surgeon and safety board.
- The robot never changes its own protocol, thresholds or limits.
comms:
  live: >-
    Low Earth orbit: red flags reach the flight surgeon within minutes; routine logs are reviewed at the
    private medical conference.
  loss_of_signal:
  - Only the robot pauses; crew care never waits for the link or the robot.
  - >-
    The robot pauses any movement and tells the CMO; on the CMO's confirmation it keeps running check-ins
    and logging offline.
  - Red-flag answers go to the CMO at once; the CMO decides under the pre-approved onboard checklist.
  - 'At the next contact the robot sends one package: answers, alerts and decisions.'
  mars_delay:
  - >-
    Replies may take up to about 21-23 minutes each way, with blackouts of about 2-3 weeks, so the CMO
    acts on red flags onboard.
  - >-
    Red flags, the check-in schedule and the onboard plan for suspected nerve-root compression are set
    before flight.
sources:
- key: kerstman
  text: >-
    Kerstman EL, Scheuring RA, Barnes MG, DeKorse TB, Saile LG. Space adaptation back pain: a retrospective
    study. Aviat Space Environ Med. 2012;83(1):2-7.
  url: https://doi.org/10.3357/asem.2876.2012
  doi: 10.3357/asem.2876.2012
  pmid: '22272509'
  supports: >-
    Space adaptation back pain in 52% of astronauts (382/728); mild in 86%, moderate in 11%, severe in
    3% of those affected; fetal positioning (91%) and analgesic medicines and exercise (85% each) were
    the most effective treatments; usually mild and self-limited, but moderate or severe pain that does
    not respond carries a risk of functional impairment and mission impact.
- key: johnston
  text: >-
    Johnston SL, Campbell MR, Scheuring R, Feiveson AH. Risk of herniated nucleus pulposus among U.S.
    astronauts. Aviat Space Environ Med. 2010;81(6):566-574.
  url: https://doi.org/10.3357/asem.2427.2010
  doi: 10.3357/asem.2427.2010
  pmid: '20540448'
  supports: >-
    In-flight back pain is presumably due to elongation of the spine; disc herniation was 4.3 times more
    common in US astronauts (321) than matched controls (983), relatively more often in the neck (18 of
    44 astronaut herniations, against 3 of 35 in controls), with evidence that the risk is increased immediately
    after spaceflight. Used here for the neck red flag; no guideline listing spinal-cord (myelopathy)
    red flags was verified for this draft, so that wording is a clinical judgment.
- key: mtb004
  text: >-
    NASA OCHMO. Space Adaptation Sickness (SAS) and Space Readaptation Syndrome. Medical Technical Brief
    OCHMO-MTB-004 Rev A (Sept 25, 2025).
  url: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/ochmo-mtb-004-space-adaptation-sickness-sas.pdf
  supports: >-
    Space adaptation back pain occurs in 52% of space travelers in the first 2-5 days of flight; microgravity
    reduces the usual curve of the back, causing it to straighten. Urinary retention can occur in the
    first few days of flight.
- key: girftces
  text: >-
    NHS England Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT). Spinal Surgery: National Suspected Cauda Equina Syndrome
    (CES) Pathway (February 2023). Also hosted by an NHS trust: https://www.gloshospitals.nhs.uk/media/documents/GIRFT_CES_Guidelines_2023_EJRRVj5.pdf
    (the copy that was read; the GIRFT-hosted copy could not be opened by automated retrieval).
  url: >-
    https://gettingitrightfirsttime.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/National-Suspected-Cauda-Equina-Pathway-February-2023-FINAL-V1-1.pdf
  supports: >-
    Emergency referral for back or leg pain with recent onset of: difficulty starting to pass urine or
    impaired sensation of urine flow; altered perianal, perineal or genital (saddle) sensation; severe
    or progressive weakness of both legs; loss of the feeling of rectal fullness; or sexual dysfunction.
    Sudden pain down both legs, or one-leg pain that spreads to both, is a warning sign. No single symptom
    has good diagnostic accuracy, and negative physical tests do not rule out cauda equina syndrome if
    the symptoms are present; bladder scans should not be used in isolation or as a discriminator.
- key: ng59
  text: >-
    National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s: assessment
    and management. NICE guideline NG59 (2016, last updated July 29, 2026).
  url: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng59/chapter/Recommendations
  supports: >-
    Think about alternative diagnoses, particularly with new or changed symptoms, and exclude specific
    causes of low back pain such as cancer, infection, trauma or inflammatory disease.
- key: gulati
  text: >-
    Gulati M, Levy PD, Mukherjee D, et al. 2021 AHA/ACC/ASE/CHEST/SAEM/SCCT/SCMR guideline for the evaluation
    and diagnosis of chest pain. Circulation. 2021;144(22):e368-e454.
  url: https://doi.org/10.1161/CIR.0000000000001029
  doi: 10.1161/CIR.0000000000001029
  pmid: '34709879'
  supports: >-
    Sudden onset of ripping chest pain (with radiation to the upper or lower back) is suspicious of an
    acute aortic syndrome.
- key: renal
  text: 'NASA Human Research Program. Evidence Report: Risk of Renal Stone Formation (2024).'
  url: https://humanresearchroadmap.nasa.gov/evidence/other/2024%20Renal%20Evidence%20Report_Final.pdf
  supports: >-
    The increased risk of renal stone formation occurs rapidly during spaceflight and continues throughout
    the mission; stones can cause renal colic or severe flank pain, blood in the urine, infection or sepsis;
    there have been no symptomatic kidney stones in flight to date in US crewmembers on the ISS.
- key: ermed
  text: >-
    NASA Human Research Program. Evidence Report: Risk of Adverse Health Outcomes and Decrements in Performance
    due to In-Flight Medical Conditions (2017).
  url: https://humanresearchroadmap.nasa.gov/evidence/reports/Medical.pdf
  supports: >-
    Table 2: 382 space adaptation back pain events among US astronauts (Shuttle, Mir and ISS through 2006);
    Table 1: 1.99 back pain events per person-year on the ISS.
- key: tb044
  text: NASA OCHMO. Medical Operations. Technical Brief OCHMO-TB-044 (2025).
  url: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/ochmo-tb-044-medical-operations.pdf
  supports: >-
    The crew surgeon keeps medical authority when care is delegated; crew medical officers train on the
    JSC 48522 medical checklist.
- key: v1
  text: 'NASA. NASA-STD-3001, Space Flight Human-System Standard, Volume 1: Crew Health, Revision C (2023).'
  url: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/nasa-std-3001-vol-1-rev-c-with-signature.pdf
  supports: Requirement IDs beginning V1.
- key: v2
  text: >-
    NASA. NASA-STD-3001, Volume 2: Human Factors, Habitability, and Environmental Health (Rev F, 2026),
    including Section 10.6 Automated and Robotic Systems.
  url: https://standards.nasa.gov/standard/NASA/NASA-STD-3001_VOL_2
  supports: Requirement IDs beginning V2.
- key: marsdelay
  text: >-
    NASA. Mars communications disruption and delay (fact sheet, 2023 Moon to Mars Architecture Concept
    Review).
  url: https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/mars-communications-disruption-and-delay.pdf
  supports: >-
    One-way Earth-Mars delay up to about 21-23 minutes, plus blackouts of about 2-3 weeks near solar conjunction.
- key: pccp
  text: >-
    U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Marketing submission recommendations for a predetermined change
    control plan for artificial intelligence-enabled device software functions (guidance).
  url: >-
    https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/marketing-submission-recommendations-predetermined-change-control-plan-artificial-intelligence
  supports: A model for planning, validating and rolling back software updates.
- key: faa460
  text: 'U.S. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 14, Part 460: Human space flight requirements.'
  url: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-III/subchapter-C/part-460
  supports: >-
    Federal rules for crew and spaceflight participants on licensed commercial flights; they set no medical
    standards for spaceflight participants.
corrections:
- date: '2026-10-20'
  version: '0.2'
  source: >-
    AI-assisted clinical and source review by the Medical Research Assistant, Oct 20, 2026 (batch 2 review)
  items:
  - >-
    Added RF12: with neck pain, new arm or hand weakness, numbness or tingling, clumsy hands, or new trouble
    with balance or walking (URGENT). Source: Johnston 2010 neck-disc data; no myelopathy guideline was
    verified (item 9).
  - >-
    Added RF13 and a stop rule: sudden severe tearing or ripping back pain, or back pain with chest or
    belly pain, fainting or breathlessness, as a possible aortic emergency (URGENT; RMP-CARD-002; Gulati
    2021) (item 10).
  - >-
    D1: a normal CMO examination does not cancel a "yes" answer; added RF14 for new one-leg symptoms at
    "CMO assesses" level (item 11).
  - >-
    RF1: early-flight urinary retention can mask or look like nerve compression; never downgraded by time
    since launch (item 12).
  - >-
    RF9 now cites the NASA renal stone evidence report and says the risk of stones is raised in flight
    (not that stones are common) (item 13).
  - >-
    Johnston wording: risk increased immediately after flight; the study looked at diagnoses after flight
    (item 14).
  - >-
    The GIRFT cauda equina pathway is cited at its GIRFT address, with the NHS trust copy as a mirror
    (item 15).
  - >-
    Each red-flag decision now applies the action listed for each matching red flag (URGENT alert, stop,
    or private flag), not URGENT for everything (review item 47).
  - >-
    Repeat check-ins inside an open log are now on-screen prompts; the robot approaches only when the
    crewmember or CMO accepts, and a prompt never starts it (item 49, [V2 10174]).
  - >-
    Red flags that had no source now cite one where a source fits; the rest are shown as general clinical
    red flags with no source cited (item 50).
  - >-
    The "item that failed a check" lockout is kept and now notes that it applies when RMP-PHARM-001 is
    used (item 51).
  - NASA evidence reports are cited as "approved for public release" (item 48).
- date: '2026-10-21'
  version: '0.3'
  source: Batch 7 editorial (AI-assisted), Oct 21, 2026
  items:
  - >-
    Citation labels changed to the site's year-only convention: "(approved for public release <date>)"
    now reads "(YYYY)", and NASA-STD-3001 Volume 2 "Revision F (approved July 14, 2026)" now reads "(Rev
    F, 2026)" (sources: ermed, renal, v2). Editorial; no change to steps, thresholds or limits.
- date: '2026-10-21'
  version: '0.4'
  source: Batch 7 review and batch 8 editorial (AI-assisted), Oct 21, 2026
  items:
  - >-
    X5 and the comms loss-of-signal branch now open with "Only the robot pauses; crew care never waits
    for the link or the robot." (batch 7 review suggestion 29). Editorial; robot behaviour unchanged.
